What's the Phillies' plan if J.T. Realmuto moves on? Here's a breakdown of the options if they don't bring him back.
The Phillies' catching situation is a topic of concern as the free agency period unfolds. With J.T. Realmuto's future uncertain, the team must consider their options to fill the void.
Internal Options:
Rafael Marchán and Garrett Stubbs: The Phillies have already agreed to terms with these two catchers for the 2026 season. Marchán, a switch-hitter, had a .210 batting average and .587 OPS in 118 plate appearances last season. Stubbs, on the other hand, saw more consistent at-bats in Triple-A, hitting .265 with a .754 OPS. However, both players are out of options in 2026, and their combined experience falls short of Realmuto's caliber.
Mark Kolozsvary and René Pinto: The Phillies signed these two minor league players to bolster their catching depth. Kolozsvary, 30, played 30 games last season and hasn't made a major league appearance since 2023. Pinto, 29, played 19 games for the Rays in 2024, hitting .214 with a .720 OPS. While they provide depth, they are not considered top options.
Free Agency Options:
Victor Caratini: A switch-hitter who slashed .259/.324/.404 in 114 games for the Astros in 2025 with 12 homers. He posted 0.9 WAR in 2025. Caratini is a more established name but falls short of Realmuto's defensive prowess.
Jonah Heim: A veteran option after being non-tendered by the Rangers. Heim hit .213 with 11 home runs in 124 games and posted 0.4 WAR last season. He is a downgrade from Realmuto in terms of defensive ability.
Trade Options:
Harry Ford: The Nationals' top catching prospect, acquired in a trade for reliever José A. Ferrer. Ford is a potential long-term solution but may not be available.
Adley Rutschman: The Orioles' catcher, who was the subject of trade rumors after signing Samuel Basallo to an extension. Rutschman is considered a front-line catcher and could be a viable option.
Ryan Jeffers: The Twins' catcher, entering his final season of team control. Jeffers could be a trade chip for the Twins as they rebuild after their fire sale in 2025.
Tyler Stephenson: The Reds' catcher, who becomes a free agent in 2027. Stephenson could be a trade chip for the Reds, who have some flexibility at the position.
The Phillies' strategy will depend on their evaluation of these options and their willingness to make a significant move to fill the void left by Realmuto's potential departure.
